I am currently in a doctoral program, studying semiotics—cultural symbols—which requires a great deal of reading. Probably the greatest benefit of an education is the wise guide (teacher) who can give a curated tour of the best there is in any given subject, and such is the case with this program. Dr. Leonard Sweet has opened the door to an entire world of scholars and theologians who look beneath the surface of things and reveal mysteries. Now I would like to open that world to you.


A rollicking good read, and every page fascinated. The research that went into this book! From the history of “woke” to the Lennon’s own two songs, one “hard” and one “soft” (in 1976, I was stopped at the threshold between East and West Berlin, and had one of my songbooks confiscated—John Lennon’s “Imagine” was in it, along with a few other unauthorized political songs. I felt lucky I got to keep my guitar).

And also, now you know why gay marriage became a key social and political touchpoint.

True Love

“To be in love became the summit of human experience an – idea which would have struck Aristotle or Ovid as outlandish in the extreme. And if you had never known love, you had not really lived at all”

Ferdinand Mount, Soft: A Brief History of Sentimentality, 3.

When the consummation of romantic love is considered the peak human experience (and Christians feel the same way; when really our message is that union with God through Jesus is the peak human experience), then marriage becomes not even simply a core human right/rite, but a basic human necessity to truly live.

Mount mentions Barbara Cartland, and I laughed out loud. My sister and I, back in 1978, went through every Cartland romance we could find just to see if she really did recycle material. Answer? Yepper. “She raised a trembling hand to still the tumult in her breast.” It’s poetical, isn’t it.

Semiology of Hard and Soft

Mount provides a sturdy defense for semiology, and we can see his use and understanding of the imagery and symbology of both hard and soft cultural phenomena. Good ole Greeks. Hard is masculine, manly, the ascendancy of reason, the suppression of feeling (sentimentality), and contempt of women. Soft is female, feminine, sentimental, and honoring of women. I see this as Genesis 3 and John 20 duking it out.

Hard champions iconoclastic purges. Soft promotes compassion with hospitals and laws that protect the vulnerable and marginalized. Hard considers itself purist, morally unimpeachable, scions of virtue, intellectually and even racially superior, “iron orthodoxy” (173). Puritans are hard. Soft is more concerned with things like the Beatitudes and the fruit of the Spirit. Methodists are soft. I appreciated all through the book how Mount not only pointed these markers out, but also applauded those who championed women. I’ll have to read a Richardson novel, now.

Imagine all the children in a classroom, maybe fourth grade. “What would you like to do when you grow up, Tommy?” ”I wanna be a pilot!” How about you, Joey?” I’m gonna be doctor!” And you, you little Dickens? “I’m going to write a dangerous novel that everyone will love to bits except the intelligentsia. They’ll hate it” (151)

As I read, it occurred to me that just as with human relationships, society experiences a regular ebb and flow of hard (distant, stiff) and soft (intimate, open). I used to call it the rubberband effect. A couple gets really close so that they are practically melded together. Until both find themselves gasping for oxygen, and they stretch apart to get some space. Something snaps, and their close again until they suffocate, and then they back off for a bit.

Mount notes that the most recent soft began in the early sixties, and he sees soft tapering off. UK has their Brexit, we have here in the USA Christian Nationalism. The iconoclasts started their work in earnest two years ago. I about gasped when I read Mount’s list:

  1. Rule of a heroic master race
  2. Selective breeding (full quiver, anyone?)
  3. Extermination of the unfit (if you can’t come into the office, government worker, you’re fired)
  4. Contempt for suburbia (in the art and literature world for sure)
  5. Dead souls of the masses (on both sides of the aisle)
  6. Identification of the [in this case, immigrant] as the corrupter of modern society

“Sentimentality … is indispensable to human flourishing. A society that is incapable of sentimentality is thereby shrivelled, a harder, lesser place”

Ferdinand Mount, Soft: A Brief History of Sentimentality, 268.

His pointed irony in choosing Lady Macbeth for hard and her husband for soft, with the milk of human kindness, was downright brilliant.

So, I have decided, writing novels is how to deal with the hard that is convulsing into life, here in the US. That is the first thing I am going to do when I graduate.

Get out your handkerchiefs!


Leave a Reply